Techsurvivors

Archives => 2008 => Topic started by: gunug on February 07, 2008, 09:05:45 AM

Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: gunug on February 07, 2008, 09:05:45 AM
I'm trying to use an external firewire drive to boot and copy partition images on the internal drive partitions of a 20" iMAC Intel.  Things worked until I updated the external drive to 10.5.1 and then I could no longer boot from the external drive.  On a hunch I went ahead and updated the internal system to 10.5.1 and now I can't seem to see the external drives at all.  Anyone else heard of this problem?
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: Paddy on February 07, 2008, 12:45:52 PM
The Apple forums are littered with people having issues of various sorts with FW drives and Leopard. Haven't yet found a sure-fire set of fixes. sad.gif

A few things to consider:

http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=88338
http://www.macfixit.com/article.php?story=20041221081432908

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?m...83&#6290683

What make and model of external drive is this?
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on February 07, 2008, 08:34:59 PM
I am experiencing a similar issue. I don't have any issues booting, but the internal boot drive isn't showing on my desktop or sidebar along with any of my FireWire hard drives which are 500GB Segate and a couple of OWC Neptune drives built as a raid. The second internal drive that I use for back up is showing up fine.

I have a few aliases set up to various folders from the FireWire drives and I can use them no problem. And I can still boot and navigate but have to jump through some hoops to get the root level of the internal hard drive.

I haven't figured out a fix yet.


Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: Paddy on February 07, 2008, 08:40:35 PM
Welcome, FultonKBD! biggrin.gif

There is a script link at the end of this Apple thread that fixed things for one person:

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?m...96&#5972596
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on February 07, 2008, 08:51:46 PM
QUOTE(Paddy @ Feb 7 2008, 09:40 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Welcome, FultonKBD! biggrin.gif

There is a script link at the end of this Apple thread that fixed things for one person:

http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?m...96&#5972596



Thanks for the greeting and thanks for the link. I'll take a look.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: gunug on February 08, 2008, 01:08:31 AM
Paddy, and everyone the final thread   ( http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?m...83&#6290683 )
describes my problem to a "T" and I'm convinced that it's not the connections or anything else but something to do with updating to 10.5.1 or an update that went through at the same time.  I'll try some things tomorrow including changing to an external USB 2.00 adapter that I have here at home.  The firewire is one made by TEAC and and hasn't failed me yet although it is only a 400 Mbit/s and not an 800!

Welcome to TS FultonKBD!  I looked at your profile (to see if you might be from Fulton, MO) & enjoyed looking at your website as well.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: Gregg on February 08, 2008, 07:24:06 AM
QUOTE(gunug @ Feb 8 2008, 01:08 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Welcome to TS FultonKBD!  I looked at your profile (to see if you might be from Fulton, MO).


Nope! From NEO. Spent a year there one day... I think.

welcome.gif FultonNEO, wherever you are.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on February 08, 2008, 08:26:30 AM
Thanks to everyone who has welcomed me. Nope not from MO, the Fulton comes from Canal Fulton which is near Akron, OH.

So last night I tried the AppleScript from the link Paddy posted. It worked for each drive until I went to run it for the last drive. When I applied the script, the Finder quit as it should and the other drives I ran through the script disappeared again.

So I'm back to square one.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: Paddy on February 08, 2008, 10:24:35 AM
Weird. Can you run it on the one that it didn't work on (first) and see what happens? If it still doesn't work, you could at least get the others working (maybe - testing would be in order of course).

Wonder if there is something in the firmware of the last drive that doesn't play nice with 10.5.1?
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: gunug on February 08, 2008, 10:39:09 AM
I'm having somewhat the same problem after having switched the drive up to a USB 2.00 box.  I'm going to reinstall 10.5 and I'm not going to let it update!  I think there is something in 10.5.1 that is not ready for prime time!  

Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on February 08, 2008, 10:40:07 AM
QUOTE(Paddy @ Feb 8 2008, 11:24 AM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Weird. Can you run it on the one that it didn't work on (first) and see what happens? If it still doesn't work, you could at least get the others working (maybe - testing would be in order of course).

Wonder if there is something in the firmware of the last drive that doesn't play nice with 10.5.1?


I continued trying various orders of the hard drives but the Apple script doesn't do anything at all to any drive. I was able to get the boot drive to show and stay shown but the other internal partition is still invisible and all the FireWire drives are still invisible.



Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: Paddy on February 08, 2008, 11:24:25 AM
Out of curiosity (and you may have gone through this already) - how did you apply the 10.5.1 update? Have you tried reapplying the combo update? This problem isn't universal - probably the majority of people have NOT had this issue, so it's hard to say whether it's something in the 10.5.1 update or some other factor that may not appear to be related, but in fact is.

What happens if you start up as a different user? Or in Safe Mode? Any differences? Does Disk Utility see the drives? Can you unmount them and then mount them again? (My externals disappear and then reappear in the sidebar when I do this, as one would expect)

Have you tried trashing the Finder .plist and then restarting? Resetting the PRAM (it does store info about the startup volume, so might be worth a shot)

These may all be long shots, but possibly worth a go if you haven't tried them yet.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on February 08, 2008, 11:50:52 AM
QUOTE(Paddy @ Feb 8 2008, 12:24 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Out of curiosity (and you may have gone through this already) - how did you apply the 10.5.1 update? Have you tried reapplying the combo update? This problem isn't universal - probably the majority of people have NOT had this issue, so it's hard to say whether it's something in the 10.5.1 update or some other factor that may not appear to be related, but in fact is.

What happens if you start up as a different user? Or in Safe Mode? Any differences? Does Disk Utility see the drives? Can you unmount them and then mount them again? (My externals disappear and then reappear in the sidebar when I do this, as one would expect)

Have you tried trashing the Finder .plist and then restarting? Resetting the PRAM (it does store info about the startup volume, so might be worth a shot)

These may all be long shots, but possibly worth a go if you haven't tried them yet.


Actually, I haven't really done any troubleshooting with the problem. Partly because I've been busy. Partly because after upgrading to Leopard I've had a few quirky issues like this. (I just upgraded the system, not archive and install. Plus, I am always messing with my system, installing/uninstalling software and stuff. So it's probably me, not necessarily Leopard.) And partly because this issue hasn't really disrupted my work flow enough.

I was looking for a quick fix and thought I found it with that AppleScript.

To answer your questions - The issue is for all the user accounts. Haven't tried safe mode. Disk Utility can see/verify/repair/mount/unmount the drives. Haven't reset the PRAM and haven't trashed the finder.plist file. So now I will need take some time and troubleshoot to figure it out.

Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: gunug on February 08, 2008, 01:47:43 PM
The iMAC 20" will find and bootup on the external drive just fine with 10.5 installed on the external drive.  I'm in the process of making an image onto a secondary partition on that drive and while slow it seems to be doing just fine.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: dolphin on February 08, 2008, 02:34:37 PM
Welcome FultonKBD...from another Ohioan. I'm from Newark and there are several other Ohioans here. You have already realized that there is some very very good help and knowledge here. Again... welcome.gif glad to have you aboard!!!  biggrin.gif
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: krissel on February 09, 2008, 04:14:26 AM
welcome.gif FultonKBD!


This is pretty basic but have you checked your Finder preferences to be sure you have the box checked to show drives, etc. on the desktop? If so, perhaps this preference is corrupt, though it would have to be corrupt even in another user's account. Thinking.gif

But it wouldn't hurt to remove it, log out and back, or restart and see if there is any change... user/you/library/prefs/finder.plist

Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: MamaMoose on February 10, 2008, 02:33:23 AM
I wonder why this problem has not been solved by someone writing software that could be used by anyone who doesn't have the knowledge or desire to poke around in the Terminal or to invoke ApplesScript.

MamaMoose
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: gunug on February 12, 2008, 07:37:24 AM
This problem also exists in 10.5.1 for a USB 2.00 drive.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on February 12, 2008, 08:32:20 AM
With Apple releasing 10.5.2 update I was hoping that it would solve my issue. But unfortunately it's still the same.

Out of my three internal drive paritions (from two drives), I was able to get two to show.

Out of my three FireWire External partitions (from two drives), I'm still not seeing them.

For my next troubleshoot, I am going to connect the FW drives to another Mac runing Tiger and see if they show up there.

Wish me luck.  smile.gif
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: krissel on February 13, 2008, 07:52:15 AM
goodluck.gif

Let us know what happens. smile.gif
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: Gregg on February 13, 2008, 08:59:36 PM
...and good luck! wish.gif

oops.gif I didn't let that "play" long enough.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on February 13, 2008, 09:57:45 PM
Thanks, will post the results. Was going to tonight but I am using the FW drive for some video work – maybe tomorrow.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on March 01, 2008, 03:03:37 PM
I'm a bit late on this. But finally did some troubleshooting. Still no luck. Even if I plug the FireWire drive into another Mac the drive still doesn't show. Also, if I connected the drive over a network (AppleShare) it doesn't show up.

Which of course makes sense, since the setting is for the drive to be invisible. I just wish I could figure out why it went invisible in the first place and why I can't get it back to visible.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: krissel on March 01, 2008, 03:53:33 PM
Sounds like the only thing you can do for now is to try that AppleScript or the terminal commands on the drives, one at a time, and immediately create an alias for each one on the desktop before you do the next. At least you would have an easier way to get to the drives.

Thinking.gif
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: gunug on March 01, 2008, 04:58:12 PM
I've gotten my cloning project figured out that this problem was standing in the way of.  What I ended up doing was setting up an external drive system (Firewire or USB2/SATA) that was bootable with just 10.5 on it.  I took that system and used it to clone off the two partitions of a Boot Camp dual-boot system.  I had to use Carbon Copy Cloner for the MAC OS side and Winclone for the XP side to make and write the partitions.  The process goes like this:

1) Setup system to clone from (I used both iMAC 20" and Intel Macbooks) and I could take the MAC OS on this system to 10.5.1/10.5.2 with no problem; the external drive doesn't seem to work over 10.5.0 though.  Use Carbon Copy Cloner and Winclone to make the images from these partitions with the system booted from one partition on the external drive and onto a second partition for storing images.  The main external drive I'm using is an external SATA 160Gig with a 40Gig part with the system and the other 120 for Data images.

2) Boot from the external drive on the next machine.  Use Drive Utility to partition the drive (30 Gig for XP / The rest MAC OS Journalized).  The XP partition to me must be set up as FAT 32 because the MAC OS can't deal with NTFS.

3) Reboot the system from a Windows XP Service Pack 2 CD and go to setup and point to the FAT32 partition.  When you tell it to "install XP" to that partition you can then choose from a menu of what to do next to the partition and one of these choices is "convert" the drive to NTFS before installing and that's what I do so the XP partition is read only to someone on the MAC side.  The tedious thing at this point is that you have to do the 1st level of the XP install (precopying set up programs which I don't use) before you're allowed a chance to reboot to the external MAC 10.5 partition to go on.

4) When it reboots you hold down the "Option" key and choose to boot off the external partition with 10.5 on it and then use WINCLONE to clone the XP image over first, then reboot to the external partition again and use Carbon Copy Cloner to clone over the MAC 10.5.1 partition with all the goodies on it (Adobe CS3, Microsoft Office 2004, a music program called Sibelius and other things for this special music program in this case).

5) Then I usually reboot to the internal MAC 10.5.1 partition and then I reboot to XP the first time (it does a 3 pass CHKDSK check) and then I have to rename the PC because our network doesn't like two PC's with the same name.

If you were to clone over the MAC partition first and then the PC you'd have to do the PC partition twice (who knows) for it to work.  This is far more than anyone wants to know but I thought I'd show my progress.  I'd like to do this from a MAC server used NETRESTORE to do all the clone work but it doesn't work yet with 10.5 all that well.  There are also UNIX ways to do all of this but I'm not ready for that sort of heavy lifting!
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: FultonKBD on March 01, 2008, 07:23:00 PM
QUOTE(krissel @ Mar 1 2008, 04:53 PM) <{POST_SNAPBACK}>
Sounds like the only thing you can do for now is to try that AppleScript or the terminal commands on the drives, one at a time, and immediately create an alias for each one on the desktop before you do the next. At least you would have an easier way to get to the drives.

Thinking.gif



Actually, an alias for each drive is exactly my work around. Hence the reason I haven't really tried to fix this. Plus I have aliases of the folders that I use the most on these drives.
Title: 10.5.1 trouble with booting/seeing external firewire?
Post by: Xairbusdriver on March 02, 2008, 03:15:15 PM
QUOTE
I thought I'd show my progress.
Not to mention your extreme patience! salute.gif