I got an email from Cafe Press the other day - the relevant bit:
The information may have included your name, email address, the password to your CafePress account, and other information (physical address, phone number, and in a small number of cases, only the last four digits of your credit number and credit card expiration date).
Like you, Kimmer, when I attempted to log in at Cafe Press, I got the "account doesn't exist" - but when I tried again now, using the "forgot password" option, sure enough, there was an account. I have now changed the PW (which oddly, was one I hadn't stored in 1Password anyway and I would have had to do the "forgot PW" thing if I'd wanted to order from them again. I don't reuse passwords, so that's not much of a concern. My CC expiration and PIN code have changed since I last ordered, and if all they have is the last 4 digits of my CC they won't get far anyway. My name, address and landline are in the phone book, so it's not as if those are of much use. The Gmail address used gets some spam - and Gmail does a great job of filtering it out, so...methinks I've done as much as I can at this point.
It IS annoying that this keeps happening.
Evite is another one that I use that got hacked recently - though the email address that shows up in HIBP is NOT either of the ones I used for accounts there (I have two - one is for an organization, the other personal), but an email address that was in HIBP was in one of the contact/invitee lists. So all they got with that one was the name and the email address. Again...no biggie, but all the Evite PWs have been changed anyway.