Another result of 'bundling'. It's hardly ever a good deal whether it's in software or anything else. There's usually too much of one thing and not enough of another, one size hardly ever fits everyone. That said, you will be lucky to even have a choice between two telecoms and/or two cable companies. So you end up trying to compare apples and oranges.
In my opinion, your choice is between fairly fast downloading, slower uploading and channels you don't watch, on the one hand. Your second choice is faster down
and uploading and fewer wasted channels. On the Internet side, the choice is obvious. But if you treasure some of those missing channels (and you may not be the only one who misses them!), you may have to live with a slightly slower Internet!
Of course, you could also try 'un-bundling' the services and see what that would cost, probably higher but maybe not as much as you thought. And there's still your fourth choice of trying to get some of those missing channels
and the higher Internet speeds.
How's that for help? You ask about one choice and get four different ones as an 'answer'!

Maybe some darts would be easier...